Jen Manion’s thoughtful and provocative essay, The Performance of Transgender Inclusion: The pronoun go-round and the new gender binary, proposes that having participants in group spaces identify their pronouns to each other causes more harm than good. I disagree. For almost two decades, I have been working to address the harm and exclusion that trans people face that lead to astounding rates of poverty, criminalization, deportation, and interpersonal violence. I agree with Jen that there is a lot of work to be done to address these injustices, and that engaging in practices aimed at helping people refer to each other respectfully in group settings is one small part of this work. I do not agree that it is more harmful than beneficial, or that it has run its course and can be discarded.
“Having a Cause” versus Living in a Life Centered in Radical Transformation
Today is a horrifying holiday dedicated to false narratives that attempt to cover over colonialism and genocide, and also a day when many people make an effort to “give back” by volunteering somewhere. Images of friendly upper class people volunteering at soup kitchens to feed homeless people articulate charity narratives that hide the actual causes and consequences of wealth and poverty.
I am sensing, all around me these days, how desperately frustrated, scared, and angry many people are about what is going on in the world around us–climate change, war-induced famine in Yemen, imprisoned children and parents at our borders and across the land, Amazon’s takeover of our food systems and cities, superstorms and disastrous fires, and so much more. I think a lot of people are wishing they knew more about how to plug in to processes of change they can believe in. I am frustrated watching misunderstandings about what change is and how it happens (“Care about poor people? Just volunteer in a soup kitchen once a year!”) circulate widely. I think their circulation is designed to demobilize us and keep us from participating in effective strategies to build the social conditions we want and need. So here is a very rough draft of a chart and some writing about the difference between “having a cause” as it is commonly described (or worse yet, the careerist version, “social justice entrepreneurship”), and living a life focused on our commitments to radical transformation. I hope it helps us imagine more creative, robust ways of being engaged with each other and the conditions we live in as we participate in resistance and transformation.
Continue reading ““Having a Cause” versus Living in a Life Centered in Radical Transformation”
TDOR Interview with Real News Network
I had a chance to talk with The Real News Network yesterday about trans people, Trump, and mutual aid. Here it is.
How Should We Respond to the Trump Administration’s Attacks on Trans People?
For me, the conversation about the leaked Health and Human Services memo indicating the Administration’s plans to deploy an anti-trans definition of gender across several federal agencies exposes key misunderstandings about trans people, legal systems, and resistance. If you’re interested in my take, you can listen to my interview on the Citations Needed podcast, or read the op-ed I published in Truthout the day after the memo was leaked, which is below. I also want to highly recommend this article by Christoph Hanssmann which helps put the idea of genetically testing gender into perspective, and this article by Gabriel Arkles that argues that anti-trans attacks also harm non-trans women and LGBQ people and knocks down religious liberty justifications for anti-trans reforms. Continue reading “How Should We Respond to the Trump Administration’s Attacks on Trans People?”
New Paris Knox Video for Survived and Punished
New Joan Little Video for Survived and Punished
New Marissa Alexander Video for Survived and Punished
The Ability to Live: What Trump’s Health Cuts Mean for People with Disabilities
My latest collaboration on disability justice: No Body Is Disposable
I’m so excited to share this new collaboration with Patty Berne and Stacey Milbern of Sins Invalid and Hope Dector of the Barnard Center for Research on Women, No Body Is Disposable: A Disability Justice Video Series.
Continue reading “My latest collaboration on disability justice: No Body Is Disposable”
My Latest Writing on Pinkwashing: The Right Wing Is Leveraging Trans Issues to Promote Militarism
I wrote this article on the dangerous ways the right is using trans people to promote right-wing security and military agendas alongside its violent backlash against trans people. Among these tactics is the Israeli government’s “Brand Israel” campaign developed over a decade ago to promote a positive public image of Israel, foment anti-Muslim racism, and distract from Israel’s brutal occupation of Palestine and apartheid regime.
Excerpt: “[T]he use of a thin LGBT inclusion politics to make the Israeli or US military appear progressive is becoming a losing strategy. Resistance to pinkwashing is rising, and each controversy exposes new communities to the critique of this propaganda. A growing number of Jews in the US, especially young people, are becoming critical of Israel. The Movement for Black Lives has made its solidarity with the struggle for Palestinian liberation clear, helping many people in the US see the connections between US and Israeli racism and state violence. Cross-movement organizing between Indigenous people in North America, including Water Protectors, and Palestine liberation activists is helping people see the links between US and Israel as settler-colonialism.”